Teen, a U.S. Citizen, Sues Border Patrol for “Inhuman and Degrading” Search

Sunday, June 12, 2016

By Jamie Ross, Courthouse News Service

TUCSON — Border Patrol agents subjected a teenage U.S. citizen to seven hours of abusive and degrading searches and strip searches for no reason as she tried to walk home from breakfast in Nogales — then they lied about it, her attorney says.

As in many twin cities on the border, walking from Nogales, Ariz. to Nogales, Sonora for a meal is as common as walking to a McDonald’s in a city away from the border. Ashley C., a natural-born U.S. citizen, did so frequently, with her birth certificate and State of Arizona identification card.

But on Oct. 14, 2014, she says, a Border Patrol agent accused her of carrying drugs, without cause. He arrested her, took her to a detention room, handcuffed her to a chair, had her sniffed by dogs, and strip-searched by women agents.

The “extremely petite” 18-year-old was never informed of her legal rights, nor was she allowed to call her mother. Nor did the agents or the dogs find any drugs. But that didn’t stop them from taking her to a hospital, in handcuffs, to be X-rayed and strip-searched more thoroughly, she says in the June 8 complaint in Federal Court.

Defendant Border Patrol Agent Shameka Leggett signed a U.S. Public Health Services Division of Immigration Health Services’ Treatment Authorization Request, according to the complaint. It continues: “Ashley was ‘diagnosed’ as an alleged ‘potential internal carrier of foreign substance’ and the ‘course of treatment’ was identified as ‘request for X-Ray.’ It is unclear what possible basis existed for CBP to use an Immigration Health Services’ form or procedure on a citizen of the United States.”

Ashley’s attorney Brian Marchetti said in an interview that the hospital’s records falsely indicate that Ashley was accompanied by her mother.

“They should have said in handcuffs accompanied by uniformed law enforcement officials,” Marchetti said. “There’s no indication [in hospital records] that an X-ray was performed,” Marchetti added.

Holy Cross Hospital and Dr. Patrick Martinez are also named as defendants, along with agent Leggett and the United States.

The complaint cites a litany of abuses:

— “Dr. Martinez forcefully and digitally probed Ashley’s vagina and anus.

— “Ashley had never before been to a gynecologist and, for the remainder of her life, will always remember that her first pelvic and rectal exams were under the most inhumane circumstances imaginable to a U.S. citizen at a hospital on U.S. soil.

— “Ashley was shocked and humiliated by these exceedingly intrusive searches. That an audience of CBP agents and Holy Cross staff observed her being probed compounded her feeling of degradation.

— “No drugs were found inside Ashley, who was then discharged from Holy Cross and transported, by CBP, back to the Port of Entry.

— “Ashley was released from custody without any charges at approximately 8:00 p.m., only after enduring roughly seven hours of dehumanizing, invasive and degrading searches.

— “Throughout the unreasonable searches of Ashley’s body cavities, she continually denied smuggling drugs internally and continually refused consent for each search.

— “At no point during the searches of Ashley did the CBP agents obtain a warrant authorizing a search of her body.”

Ashley says she’s not the only one. Holy Cross and Customs and Border Protection have a “pattern and practice of jointly conducting law enforcement searches in an unreasonable manner and without a warrant or sufficient suspicion,” the complaint states. It also says that Holy Cross has not trained its employees “on the constitutional limits constraining those searches.”

“We hope to prevent this from happening to anybody else,” Marchetti said.

Ashley seeks punitive damages for civil rights violations, including false arrest, false imprisonment, unreasonable search and seizure and deprivation of due process, negligent hiring, training and supervision, and assault and battery.

A spokesman for Customs and Border Protection said it does not comment on pending litigation.

In December 2013, a 54-year-old woman sued the University Medical Center of El Paso and several Border Patrol agents, after being subjected to body cavity searches for six hours at the border after a drug-sniffing dog jumped on her.

The hospital paid the woman $1.1 million in a July 2014 settlement, and agreed to review its policies.


To Learn More:

Citizens’ Growing Protests against Border Patrol Checkpoints Inside the U.S. (by Danny Biederman and Noel Brinkerhoff, AllGov)

10 Lawsuits Filed against Border Patrol for Abuse (by Matt Bewig, AllGov)

Tasers Became Weapon for Use of Excessive Force by Border Patrol (by Noel Brinkerhoff and Steve Straehley, AllGov)


Steve 8 years ago
Probable cause did not exist. When those responsible are sued we will see how this plays out. All I can say is that it won't be pretty.
S Spencer 8 years ago
US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) is made up of many subordinate organizations and job descriptions. You state that it was the US Border Patrol, you are incorrect. Your reporting stats how tis was a Port Of Entry incident, Port Of Entries are not staffed by Border Patrol Agents, they are staffed by Customs and Border Protection Officers of the Office of Field Operations. Border Patrol Agents, a different job description and different training, mission and uniform work between the ports of entries and interior of the US.
AZ 8 years ago
Customs work at the Port of Entry and have K9s that can sniff pedestrians. Border Patrol wear green uniforms and work between the Port of Entries. She's 18, a legal Adult, she doesn't need to have her mom with her. She should know that when she tries to get back into the United States she could be searched.

Leave a comment