Budget Problems and Mistrust of Government Lead More Than 200 Districts to Stop Adding Fluoride to Water

Saturday, October 15, 2011
Local governments have been giving up for the past several years on putting fluoride in drinking water, due to budget issues and suspicions of the longstanding practice.
 
Over the last four years, about 200 communities have stopped fluoridating their water systems. This year alone 11 cities, mostly small, but including Fairbanks, Alaska, have dropped fluoride. The most recent jurisdiction to eliminate fluoride is Pinellas County, Florida, which includes the city of St. Petersburg.
 
Some officials say the change was prompted by lack of funds. Others question the value of putting fluoride in water, echoing the worries expressed by conservatives during the Cold War that fluoridation was a Communist plot.
 
Federal health officials continue to insist fluoride is a good thing, saying it’s been responsible for a 25% reduction in tooth decay in the U.S.
 
But Washington also has undercut its own argument supporting fluoride. A 2010 report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said the substance had led to an increase in dental fluorosis (white or yellow spots on teeth) among children 12 to 15 years old.
-Noel Brinkerhoff
 

Florida's Pinellas County Rejects Fluoride in Drinking Water (by Rick Jervis, USA Today) 

Comments

nyscof 12 years ago
prominent dentists say drinking fluoridated water is risky breaking away from dental school dogma, more dentists are speaking out against fluoridation because fluoride chemicals, added to water supplies intending to reduce tooth decay, are actually a money-wasting health risk seven nyc council members sponsored legislation (1) and residents are petitioning mayor bloomberg to stop fluoridation, to preserve money and health. join them: http://www.change.org/petitions/stop-fluoridation-in-new-york-city hydrofluosilicic acid, a lead- and arsenic-laced chemical (2) left-over from making phosphate fertilizer (3) is nyc's fluoride chemical of choice. fluoridation cost nyc approximately $25 million in 2008.(4) dentist caree alexander, a former navy practitioner, then a private practice dentist for 20 years, says fluoridation is "totally ineffective and actually damaging as well."(5) dr. alexander says, "when i graduated from university, we weren't given any information about where [fluoride] came from. we all assumed it was [pharmaceutical-grade] calcium fluoride." prominent nyc dentist and huffington post contributor, dr. thomas connelly, writes, "i do not see the good in fluoridating our drinking water ... to me, the 'bad' it can (potentially) do outweighs the good."(6) dr. andrew harms, former president, australian dental association, who once supported fluoridation, says, "i deeply regret this ... when i did read the science about 10 years ago, i started to get serious concerns." dr. harms says, "to my amazement, when i tried to raise the issue with the [australian] dental association, whom i thought were interested in the science and ... integrity, there was no interest. in fact there was a lot of pressure against me to say anything at all. there was a great concern about upsetting our principle sponsors, the toothpaste manufacturers, who heavily compromise our university," says harms in a video documentary, firewater. (7) dentist hardy limeback, ph.d., university of toronto professor and head, preventive dentistry, apologized for promoting fluoridation because toxicology research shows the purported benefits no longer outweigh the risks.(8) dentist bill osmunson, fluoride action network spokesperson, promoted fluoridation for 25 years until his patients persuaded him to read the science, "it [was] like a knee in the gut," he says. "science has turned against fluoridation and we must stop adding fluoride to water."(9) dentist david kennedy, international academy of oral medicine and toxicology (iaomt), past president and fluoride information officer, says, "water fluoridation delivers a drug to infants at a level which would be gross malpractice if prescribed by a physician or dentist." (10) iaomt is a network of dental, medical and research professionals which supports the effort to inform consumers about health risks from water fluoridation. over 3,790 professionals, including 325 dentists, signed a statement opposing water fluoridation. see statement: http://www.fluoridealert.org/professionals-statement.aspx attorney paul beeber, nyscof president, says, "the national research council reported that fluoride, even at levels used for fluoridation, can damage bones and teeth, disrupt thyroid function, be harmful to kidney patients and that studies linking fluoride to lowered iq and cancer are plausible." dentist jennifer luke, ph.d., says, "my [published] work showed that fluoride accumulates in the human pineal gland and lowers melatonin production in animals. i find it extraordinary that no government promoting fluoridation has chosen to pursue these worrying findings."(11) dentist and doctor of medical science, elise bassin, published unrefuted scientific evidence showing that fluoride can increase the risk of osteosarcoma (a type of bone cancer) in boys and young men.(12) about 250 communities have stopped fluoridation in recent years.(13) references: 1) http://legistar.council.nyc.gov/legislationdetail.aspx?id=828442&guid=b1b850e6-5bb5-4cc1-9492-6e1070a72b31&options=&search 2) http://sapphireeyesproductions.blogspot.com/ 3) http://www.cdc.gov/fluoridation/fact_sheets/engineering/wfadditives.htm 4) http://www.freewebs.com/fluoridation/newyorkcity.htm 5) video: http://www.youtube.com/user/sapphireeyesdocos#g/c/cb9c521c7cdd5c4e transcript: http://www.firewaterfilm.com/fw%20tsct-%20dr.%20caree%20alexander.pdf 6) http://www.huffingtonpost.com/thomas-p-connelly-dds/mouth-health-fluoridated_b_641767.html 7) video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1nezy2idoui transcript: http://www.firewaterfilm.com/fw%20tsct-%20dr.%20andrew%20harms.pdf 8) http://www.fluoridealert.org/limeback.aspx 9) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=roi2_3q8eok 10) http://www.sw4sc.org/mwdweb.htm 11) http://www.fluoridealert.org/statement.quotes.aug.2007.pdf 12) http://www.fluoridealert.org/fan_oehha_9_6_11.pdf 13) http://www.fluorideaction.net/communities.htm
anonymouse 12 years ago
fluoride's efficacy in reducing tooth decay has not been demonstrated generally -- only in children. so why dose the entire community with a substance that is poisonous in quantity, and cumulative in the body over time? and please remember, the stuff they dump in the public water supply is not expensive, dental-grade stannous fluoride; it is purified industrial waste containing trace amounts of heavy metals. ... "saving money" is really just a politically acceptable cop-out for never having to say "we're sorry."

Leave a comment