Why is Obama Hiding 6,000-Page Report on Bush-Era Torture and Why is Torture Still Allowed?

Monday, May 13, 2013

President Barack Obama is currently blocking the release—or allowing the CIA to block the release—of a comprehensive Senate report on the use of torture by the George W. Bush administration CIA that is said to conclude that torture was not an effective or reliable method of interrogation and that the agency repeatedly misled the White House, the Justice Department, and Congress about its interrogation efforts.


Initiated by Senate Intelligence Committee Chair Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-West Virginia) and continued by Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-California) when she succeeded him in 2009, the Senate torture probe entailed about six years of work and the review of 6 million pages of documents. In December 2012, the committee voted out the report on a mostly party line vote. Since that time, the report has been stuck in limbo at the CIA, with Director John Brennan refusing to state when his review will be complete, and reports indicating that the agency intends to write a rebuttal and oppose public release of the report.


Although the report validates anti-torture positions taken by Democrats, including President Obama, during the Bush years, Obama may be delaying its release over concerns about shedding negative light on his own, related, anti-terror policies that offend human rights, such as the continued use of torture at Guantánamo Bay or the predator drone assassination program. Further, the deep involvement of Obama's hand-picked CIA Director, John Brennan, in the Bush-era torture and kidnapping programs may call Obama’s judgment about Brennan into question.


On the issue of torture at Guantánamo, the Obama White House claimed in 2009 that the President had canceled all Bush-era legal memos purporting to justify the use of “enhanced interrogation” techniques not authorized by the Army Field Manual. The President did not, however, cancel an April 13, 2006, memo regarding the 2006 revision of the Army Field Manual and its controversial Appendix M on interrogation. That memo justifies the use of isolation, sleep deprivation, and forms of sensory deprivation that have been denounced as torture or abuse by a number of human rights and legal groups—and which sparked the ongoing hunger strike at Guantánamo.


Obama may be concerned about the impact release of the report might have on his predator drone targeted assassination program. In 2009, the Obama administration successfully persuaded the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York to overrule a trial judge’s ruling ordering release of a September 17, 2001, presidential directive that established a wide range of anti-terror efforts, including the use of torture. Why Obama went to such great lengths to keep the directive secret may have been revealed by the appeals court opinion, which stated that “the withheld information pertains to intelligence activities unrelated to the discontinued [torture] program,” including targeted killings of suspected al-Qaeda operatives. 

-Matt Bewig


To Learn More:

Why is Obama Withholding Secret Torture Report from Americans? (by Marcy Wheeler, Salon)

The Torture Memo Obama Never Rescinded (by Jeffrey Kaye, Public Record)

The Absurdity of Letting the CIA Vet the Torture Report (by Conor Friedersdorf, The Atlantic) 

Bipartisan Study Concludes Bush Administration “Indisputably” Sanctioned U.S. Use of Torture (by Danny Biederman and Noel Brinkerhoff, AllGov)

Senate Report on CIA Torture Techniques May Remain Secret (by Matt Bewig, AllGov)


jackfkelly 11 years ago
It is a true paradox that the Executive Branch has declined to investigate war crimes. However it stands in stark contrast to the Republican scorched earth policy of investigating everything including nail biting.
KingofthePaupers 11 years ago
Jct: It's still reassuring to know that the documentation of the Bush Gang's Crimes against humanity is on record. 6 million pages worth of crime details. Quite reassuring even if it hasn't yet come out to know it's there ready to come out at any time.
Patrick 11 years ago
Anyone who will torture, will ENSLAVE. They are the same thing. Using pain to extract what you want from another Human. Any government that will delete one of the RIGHTS from the Bill of RIGHTS .... will delete the 13th Amendment as well. Any government that is BANKRUPT and desperate for money "By Any Means" .........

Leave a comment